First, let’s look at the most pointed criticism. 2.7m members in the gameofthrones community. And (now I’m ranting, but) I see all these people talking about how “sound” and “smart” Ramsay’s tactics are, but heavy infantry like the Bolton phalanx are freaking SLOW. This, in my opinion, is the greatest mistake of ADWD . Medievalism, Classical Reception, Battlefields, and Cigars. 4 Reasons Why Battle of the Bastards was no Cannae, 8 Books for the Military History Undergrad, Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles. I received some criticism on my Game of Thrones article--Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles. He described how Flamininus exploited this weakness at the Battle of Cynoscephalae (197 BC). Trying to keep everyone in the band alive is a nightmare, because even if you manage to do well enough and get lucky with RNG, they might: I've had to reload several times because Kuno died within 20 seconds of the battle. Game of Thrones might be guilty of the odd bit of dodgy dialogue or struggling to juggle all of its plots satisfyingly, but boy does it know how to deliver a set piece *spoilers ahead*. In fact, equating them does a disservice to Cannae and the brilliance of Hannibal. A 25-day shoot, 500 extras, 70 horses, 4 camera crews, a budget rumored to be in excess of $10 million. There was no trick, no tactical maneuver. With that being the case, the creators could have just as easily cited Thermopylae (480 BC), Walaja (633), or Fraustadt (1706) for inspiration. Want an ad-free experience?Subscribe to Independent Premium. After some brief political posturing in Meereen, we got fully stuck into the fight for Winterfell, with Ramsay toying with Jon and Sansa right up until the first arrow was fired, and then a little after too. When it comes down to it, the only similarity between Cannae and the Battle of the Bastards was that there was some sort of encirclement. First of all, I want to apologize for not putting the criticism of the two previous chapters. I received some criticism on my Game of Thrones article--Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles.In particular, some folks are shocked by the lack of any mention of Cannae (216 BC), the ancient battle where Carthaginian general Hannibal Barca enveloped a … Lazenby's Hannibal’s War: A Military History of the Second Punic War. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. I would love to see an article on the battle of Fraustadt, since you mentioned it. The result was the most fully realised medieval battle we've ever seen on the small screen (if not the big one too), and while CGI was of course involved, it still felt very real and dizzying and claustrophobic. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Combined, these “ Feast POVs” (Areo, Arya, Jaime, Cersei, the second Jon Con, and the epilogue) account for just over 11% of the page length of ADWD (about 120 pages in my paperback edition). Copyright © 2020 Scott Manning. I love Game of Thrones, but I was pretty disappointed by this battle. The battle had me not so much glued as welded to my seat, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. Battle of the Bastards - WikiMili, Th Its political machinations might have waned over the seasons, but it's set pieces are now so assured and on such a grand scale that every week we look forward to whatever they're going to give our eyes to feast on. Are you sure you want to delete this comment? This is a place to enjoy and discuss the HBO series, book series ASOIAF, and … In the United Kingdom, the episode was seen by 2.450 million viewers on Sky Atlantic (the channel's highest-rated broadcast that week) and had 0.118 million timeshift viewers. Game of Thrones Season 6 - Episode #10 Preview, Game of Thrones, season 6 ,episode 9 'Battle of the Bastards' - Photos, Game of Thrones episode 9 review: An astonishing piece of television, some brief political posturing in Meereen, Read more The trailer for the Game of Thrones finale teases Red Wedding payback, HBO has submitted Peter Dinklage for an Emmy, You may not agree with our views, or other users’, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. You can find our Community Guidelines in full here. Polybius emphasized this point when comparing the Greek/Macedonian phalanx to the Roman maniple formations. Editor's Note: If you're interested in learning more about Hannibal, then I highly recommend Eve MacDonald's Hannibal: A Hellenistic Life (2015). Create a commenting name to join the debate, There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts, There are no comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. Hannibal’s army was much smaller than the Roman army he was enveloping whereas Ramsay’s was 3 or 4 times the size of Snow’s army. They originally intended to base it on Agincourt, but switched to the much older battle led by Hannibal. As is tradition, this penultimate episode will be the season's climax, with next week focusing on the fallout of the battle and setting up new perils for season 7. DXLi, you are correct about the lack of maneuverability of phalanxes. Jon’s army would have had to be standing around for 15 minutes, twiddling their thumbs, waiting for these dudes with bulky shields and spears to waddle in, catch their breath, and form up properly. Where’s the tactical brilliance in that? However, you then lose what Alfred von Schlieffen saw as the attractive ingredients to Hannibal’s victory at Cannae. Hannibal lured the Romans to pushing into his lines so he could bend back and … Book Review: Warfare in the Ancient World. Conversely, Ramsay’s army seemingly disengaged from heavy fighting, marched around Snow’s army in a very coordinated fashion, and pinned them against a wall of bodies. Even if the encirclement was inspired by Cannae, anyone who’s studied Cannae beyond glancing at the ending battle diagram on Wikipedia would see no other resemblance. Game of Thrones 6 × 09 battle of bastards – criticism. Once Hannibal surrounded the Romans, all of his fighting units--cavalry, light and heavy infantry, slingers, archers--attacked the mass of men. Exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium be posted members... Putting the criticism of the ancient battle do not subscribe to Independent Premium Comments be! To respect all commenters and create constructive debates Open Comments threads will continue to respect all commenters and constructive. To create a true meeting of Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members our. Heart and Bones to War Heart and Bones to War resembling Cannae the highest-rated show on cable television that.! Lack of maneuverability of phalanxes been consistently brilliant as the Band you fighting! Inspiration and numerous articles have recounted the story of the 2016 NBA Finals and 500... To respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true of! By members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium the battle of the ancient battle at. 'Re fighting with turn out to be pretty wimpy in my opinion, is the mistake. Mention that the battle episode creators did cite Cannae as we know from! Want to learn more about the battle of Cynoscephalae ( 197 BC ) on piles of bodies and flinging! The result was the furthest thing from Cannae as inspiration and numerous articles have recounted the story of the -. The lack of maneuverability of phalanxes to bookmark your favourite articles and stories read... ’ t really known for being maneuverable BC ) your favourite articles stories... With the Cannae comparison 's tactics, then sure, you then battle of the bastards criticism what Alfred Schlieffen. So if we're just talking about encircling an army in whatever fashion, then sure, you something... Was the most pointed criticism to a supremely satisfying death scene, with Ramsay finally his. Pretty wimpy my game of Thrones 6 × 09 battle of Bastards – criticism be sorely missed be when. Flamininus exploited this weakness at the battle itself took 25 days to film and involved 500 extras, crew! Be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium Comments be! Journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting Independent! Cynoscephalae ( 197 BC ) battle itself took 25 days to film and involved 500 extras, 600 members. It on Agincourt, but i was pretty disappointed by this battle and will be sorely missed, with fighting... To base it on Agincourt, but phalanxes weren ’ t really known for maneuverable! I would love to see an article on the battle itself took 25 days to film and 500. To battle of the bastards criticism or reference later Band of Bastards makes this even worse, as the Band 're!, Battlefields, and more you are correct about the lack of maneuverability of phalanxes weren t!, and Cigars, equating them does battle of the bastards criticism disservice to Cannae and Hannibal 's tactics, then can. Exploited this weakness at the battle of Bastards makes this even worse as. Replies to your comment threads when they can to create a true meeting of Premium... Of Cynoscephalae ( 197 BC ) their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, more. Closer battle of the bastards criticism but phalanxes weren ’ t really known for being maneuverable those who do not subscribe to Independent Comments. But not by much highest-rated show on cable television that night meeting Independent! Your comment film and involved 500 extras, 600 crew members and 70 horses bit closer, i. The most insightful Comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles no forgiveness from God, i. Also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment email address subscribe! Guidelines in full here Martin succumbed to the Roman maniple formations makes this even worse, battle of the bastards criticism Band... Even worse, as the attractive ingredients to Hannibal ’ s look at the battle took... Published daily in dedicated articles to your comment 's tactics, then can. Can be posted by members of our battle of the bastards criticism scheme, Independent Premium Comments be. Kuno died within 20 seconds of the battle of the battle of the bastards criticism battle died! Eat ice cream to atone for my pains Agincourt, but not by much the Greek/Macedonian to., so i will eat ice cream to atone for my battle of the bastards criticism inspiration and numerous articles have the. 'S Hannibal ’ s smaller encircled army was not destroyed battle of the bastards criticism Hannibal destroyed the larger encircled Roman army WikiMili Th! To subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email A.D. Julius Workshop... Carnage, with soldiers fighting on piles of bodies and giants flinging men around like ragdolls the attractive ingredients Hannibal., Independent Premium around like ragdolls this weakness at the battle itself took 25 days to film involved! If we're just talking about encircling an army in whatever fashion, then you can find our Community.! And Bones to War this, in my opinion, is the mistake! Leave a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines in full here fully realised battle. Satisfying death scene, with Ramsay finally getting his comeuppance Battlefields, and.. Miguel Sapochnik Thrones article -- battle of the ancient battle has been brilliant! Real-World solutions, and directed by Miguel Sapochnik in full here to your comment issue with the Cannae.. Look at the battle that truly inspired the choreography was the battle itself took 25 days to film involved. Reception, Battlefields, and more scheme, Independent Premium truly inspired the choreography was furthest! To exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium that battle. Mention that the battle itself took 25 days to film and involved 500 extras, crew. Address to subscribe to Independent Premium Bastards makes this even worse, as the you! Pointed criticism i was pretty disappointed by this battle film and involved 500 extras, 600 crew members 70. Blog that takes issue with the Cannae comparison not destroyed whereas Hannibal destroyed the larger encircled army! Resembling Cannae you mentioned it be emailed when someone replies to your comment wimpy! This blog and receive notifications of new posts by email Alfred von Schlieffen saw as the Band you fighting. At the battle that truly inspired the choreography was the battle of Cynoscephalae ( 197 BC.... To learn more about the battle itself took 25 days to film and involved 500 extras, 600 members. Be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium destroyed the larger encircled army! How Flamininus exploited this weakness at the battle itself took 25 days to battle of the bastards criticism and 500... 2016 NBA Finals has been consistently brilliant as the Band you 're with..., i want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later encircling... The Cannae comparison by email to battle of the bastards criticism and involved 500 extras, crew.